Personally, I'd be tempted to get a small bottle of some different ammo and see if it does the same thing (same weight, different manufacturer and different weights too if you can swing it - maybe ask a buddy if he has some spare he can let you try).
You could try swapping the hop rubber, I'd usually suggest a Maple Leaf but the Krytacs have a weird nub so I'm not sure it'll work without changing the arm a bit and then you could be introducing other problems.