Sitting Duck
Supporters
- May 11, 2014
- 4,894
- 1,735
First thing Neoprene is NOT as effective as Sobothane !!!!
Sobothane is not as cheap To do anything properly will involve a bit more time & money
Often the perfect solution will be a mix of both with neo protecting sorbo as it is a bit too squishy to be solely used
When doing AOE - every box is different - some might need 2mm correcting
others might need 5 or 6mm correction - one or two may need next to nothing
Ultimate silent piston/cylinder head needed next to nothing - well due to the size/shape I couldn't fit one really
but a smidge was required of about 1mm-ish. In this case I trimmed a neo washer (trimmed coz it does compress)
trmmed the washer - aprox 2.5mm off the washer all way round - now 15mm diameter
mount behind piston head and tightened piston & piston head - it squished a bit but dropped AOE back 1mm for better AOE
On other boxes normally 3 to 4mm is the norm. how this is performed is going down to user
The neo washers do work out a very cheap & easy method to correct this
BUT not as squishy or impact absorbing as Sorbothene.
Now Sorbo sheet can be purchased and cut/shaped/drilled but that is if you wish to do all that yourself
Airlabs sorbo pad will cost you about £9 on its own and "may" still need a little work like most stuff
Sorbothene is not as cheap as Neoprene but it does offer better impact and no doubt will prolong the gearbox against cracking
But Neoprene pad won't be worse than stock and imho will offer a bit more protection than running stock like before
I still stand by the easy to apply neo washers as a no frills easy to apply cheapo method
but have ordered up some sorbothane to make up a "proper" sorbo pad but it wasn't cheap n cheerful price
(compared to neoprene - but then the best don't come cheap)
Will it be worth it - dunno yet but it is the proper way to do it
will my gearbox with neo just break off - ergh I really don't think so as it its still a bit better than stock
Will I personally rip open previous boxes - nope lets see how bare neoprene boxes shatter
(if I re-do them I'll never know I guess)
All I will do is use a sorbo/neo combo mix in my next overhaul or if one of the old neo boxes needs attention I will perhaps re-do the pad
but I ain't gonna rip open a box just yet.
Suppose the ultimate test once finding the correct or best mix of sorbo/neo is to do do 2 brittle plastic gearboxes
and put then on 11.1v and see how quickly they shake & shatter themselves to bits
(yes sorbo is the favourite but how by how much will it beat the simple neoprene)
One final thing - often on correcting AOE you may get a small void or outer ring space if using say 20mm sorbo/neo pads
Often thought this void is a wasted space of air than isn't expelled as piston hits home
this void can be filled quite nicely with an old knackered piston o-ring and does a nice job too
(sort of helping to seal head better with an additional o-ring too)
To affix the old piston o-ring into the void around the pads you will need some super glue
depending on what you have to hand in case you do not have Loctite Super Glue.....
No to No More Nails or any other stuff - uhmmm got this Wonder or Ultra Glue tube will that do ???
look at the back and check what is in there.....
cyanoacrylate - yup that is what you want
It fuses rubber - when I say fuses I mean it don't just stick like a sticky tape or label does
it REALLY binds them together so much you will not be able to pull them apart easily without it breaking to bits
(ok you can soak them in hot soapy water but you get the idea of what I mean by fuses them together)
The neo is a cheap easy to aplly solution - not the ultimate & best solution but many seek an easy improvement
but like everything if you want the best you need to pay and often put in the time fitting stuff correctly too
if anybody is paranoid will my box break in two.....
I'm not rushing out re-doing my previous boxes just yet
I am gonna wait until next service and see how a proper sorbo/neo pad works in comparison in the mean time
Until I have done more tests though I will ease up on my own recommendations
I'm still learning and do appreciate any input that helps all of our stuff run better
Sobothane is not as cheap To do anything properly will involve a bit more time & money
Often the perfect solution will be a mix of both with neo protecting sorbo as it is a bit too squishy to be solely used
When doing AOE - every box is different - some might need 2mm correcting
others might need 5 or 6mm correction - one or two may need next to nothing
Ultimate silent piston/cylinder head needed next to nothing - well due to the size/shape I couldn't fit one really
but a smidge was required of about 1mm-ish. In this case I trimmed a neo washer (trimmed coz it does compress)
trmmed the washer - aprox 2.5mm off the washer all way round - now 15mm diameter
mount behind piston head and tightened piston & piston head - it squished a bit but dropped AOE back 1mm for better AOE
On other boxes normally 3 to 4mm is the norm. how this is performed is going down to user
The neo washers do work out a very cheap & easy method to correct this
BUT not as squishy or impact absorbing as Sorbothene.
Now Sorbo sheet can be purchased and cut/shaped/drilled but that is if you wish to do all that yourself
Airlabs sorbo pad will cost you about £9 on its own and "may" still need a little work like most stuff
Sorbothene is not as cheap as Neoprene but it does offer better impact and no doubt will prolong the gearbox against cracking
But Neoprene pad won't be worse than stock and imho will offer a bit more protection than running stock like before
I still stand by the easy to apply neo washers as a no frills easy to apply cheapo method
but have ordered up some sorbothane to make up a "proper" sorbo pad but it wasn't cheap n cheerful price
(compared to neoprene - but then the best don't come cheap)
Will it be worth it - dunno yet but it is the proper way to do it
will my gearbox with neo just break off - ergh I really don't think so as it its still a bit better than stock
Will I personally rip open previous boxes - nope lets see how bare neoprene boxes shatter
(if I re-do them I'll never know I guess)
All I will do is use a sorbo/neo combo mix in my next overhaul or if one of the old neo boxes needs attention I will perhaps re-do the pad
but I ain't gonna rip open a box just yet.
Suppose the ultimate test once finding the correct or best mix of sorbo/neo is to do do 2 brittle plastic gearboxes
and put then on 11.1v and see how quickly they shake & shatter themselves to bits
(yes sorbo is the favourite but how by how much will it beat the simple neoprene)
One final thing - often on correcting AOE you may get a small void or outer ring space if using say 20mm sorbo/neo pads
Often thought this void is a wasted space of air than isn't expelled as piston hits home
this void can be filled quite nicely with an old knackered piston o-ring and does a nice job too
(sort of helping to seal head better with an additional o-ring too)
To affix the old piston o-ring into the void around the pads you will need some super glue
depending on what you have to hand in case you do not have Loctite Super Glue.....
No to No More Nails or any other stuff - uhmmm got this Wonder or Ultra Glue tube will that do ???
look at the back and check what is in there.....
cyanoacrylate - yup that is what you want
It fuses rubber - when I say fuses I mean it don't just stick like a sticky tape or label does
it REALLY binds them together so much you will not be able to pull them apart easily without it breaking to bits
(ok you can soak them in hot soapy water but you get the idea of what I mean by fuses them together)
The neo is a cheap easy to aplly solution - not the ultimate & best solution but many seek an easy improvement
but like everything if you want the best you need to pay and often put in the time fitting stuff correctly too
if anybody is paranoid will my box break in two.....
I'm not rushing out re-doing my previous boxes just yet
I am gonna wait until next service and see how a proper sorbo/neo pad works in comparison in the mean time
Until I have done more tests though I will ease up on my own recommendations
I'm still learning and do appreciate any input that helps all of our stuff run better
Last edited by a moderator: