New Feedback System: Yay or Nay?

[proffrink]

We're coming up on two months since the new feedback system took its place on the forums. Please read all of the below before voting.

Should we keep the new feedback system?

Poll respondents with less than 5 community reputation will have their vote removed from the total. This is to stop (the admittedly slim chance) of someone creating accounts to flood the poll. The poll will close on Sunday 8th July and the result implemented by Sunday 12th July. The poll has been extended to Wednesday 11th.

If the 'new' feedback system is removed (a 'no' vote wins):

• Your feedback currently in the new feedback system will be merged back into the original topic-based feedback system
  
  
  a thread will go up where you can post your name and a member of staff will move your feedback over into your original thread (or create a new one if you don't yet have one)
  
• this 'request that my trader feedback be moved' thread will be locked after 3 months (after which, no further migrations of feedback will be made)
  

[*]The new feedback system will remain for 3 months, but no new feedback will be able to be posted

[*]The original feedback system will be made current again




If the new feedback system remains (a 'yes' vote wins):

• Your feedback currently in the 'old' thread-based feedback system will be merged into the new feedback system
  
  
  a thread will go up where you can post your name and a member of staff will move your feedback score over from your old thread
  
  
  Anything rated above 7 score will be considered 'positive'
  
• Anything rated between 3 and 7 (inclusive) will be considered 'neutral'
  
• Anything rated below 3 will be considered 'negative'
  

[*]We may not be able to move comments attached to these scores, but we will try. At a minimum your 'score' will be moved (even if it includes no comment from the original buyer/seller)

[*]this 'request that my trader feedback be moved' thread will be locked after 3 months (after which, no further migrations of feedback will be made)



[*]The original feedback system will be archived but will still be visible




This isn't a discussion topic. Go here for providing feedback and asking questions:

 

[proffrink]

Please see update on notes regarding migration of 'old' feedback score.

 

[proffrink]

I am going to extend this poll into Wednesday due to a low number of respondents. Think this is mostly down to the announcement bar I scheduled not actually showing up before the weekend like it should have.

 

[proffrink]

Yes: 13 votes

1 vote dropped due to low community reputation

Total: 12

~66.6%

No: 6

0 votes dropped due to low community reputation

Total: 6

~33.3%

New feedback will replace the old.

To apply to have your feedback migrated please post here: